In response to my second essay my Oxford tutor wrote the following:
"First things first, Paul. Apart from some minor glitches, this essay was far better written than the first one. I hope you can sustain this quality of writing - this capacity to write clear, understandable sentences - in future essay's. As to the content, the essay was also a substantial improvement on the last one. Apart from the occasional wander, the essay made a real effort to answer the question at hand and to so effectively and persuasively. You certainly drew important parallels between the first and second crusades and made them with force, and I particularly like the emphasis on evidence and named individuals."
HAHA!!! Take that Oxford.
Thanks for your prayers.
I've been couped up in my room and in various libraries for the past four days writing papers, so there isn't that much to update you on. I'm still basking in the Oxford glow here, loving every minute of it. Most of you know I'm a 'mamma's boy', and if you didn't now you do. I got to talk to her on Sunday, and just missed my Dad to another one of his road-warrior trips. So, for those of you in my immediate family reading this and I haven't talked to you in awhile, it's because I love Margaret more, ha (oh, and something to do with the deadline pressure of the most prestigious university in the world).
If there is one thing I respect about our sister country, its the fact that they know how to educate, and educate effectively. Every year of high school narrows a students subject matter so that by the time they get to University they can focus on one subject (i.e. philosophy, history, english, etc...). They spend three years at Oxford, writing for tutors who don't grade their work. Of course mine will be graded and my tutors send those grades to the SCIO office, who then send them to our home institutions) The purpose of the tutorial for British students is to prepare them for their final exams at the end of their third year, those exams are their only grades they receive while they are here. No tests, no GPA, just one set of finals. These kids are brilliant at their subject because by the time their done, they've been focusing on it for years. It just worsens my view of a broadening liberal education.
Anyway, now you know why the Brits are brilliant. As for me, I'll just keep putting the axe to the grind and reading as much as I can. I hope you're all doing well, to my bro's at Taylor, have a good J-Term break, to my bro's at OSU and Miami, I'm sorry you don't have a J-term break, to the fam, Oxford doesn't have a J-term break so I wont be seeing you this week, and to everyone else, 'till next time.
Yours, in every sense of the word.
Paul
Wednesday, 28 January 2009
Thursday, 22 January 2009
Coping with the pain...
To preface: my tutor, Dr. Hugh Doherty, is very helpful and gracious, not the harsh critic I was expecting from Oxford Professors. Here's his note to me after our first meeting yesterday (which actually went very well) discussing my first essay.
"Paul
A rather ponderous and unexciting essay. You must avoid making grand and bold explanations in complex and grandiose language. Say things simply and clearly. This essay demonstrates a great deal of hard work, but little substantive thought. Too often the essay tries to explain the genesis and formulation of crusading ideology rather than identity and discussion on the expectation of the crusaders, as required by the question. The essay needed evidence and it needed examples: it supplied neither. Above all the essay failed to address the question. There was, it is true, the occasional glimpse of an effort to do so, most notably (and this is true, alas, of many essays) in the conclusion. It is too late in the conclusion. Don't lose heart, however, learn, read, and apply these points. Doing so will not only produce the goods, but will be intellectually satisfying."
:) I don't think my parents need to worry about me losing anything from my great resevior of humility while I'm here ... haha. I think most people come here and expect to attain a certain intellectual "air" about them simply because they're at Oxford. Well, I'm glad mine got shot to the ground because it was starting to get old. The good thing about yesterday is it took alot of the pressure off. This Oxford don wants me to be down to earth, real, and simple in my writing, because, he says, thats the best kind of writing. That is something I have been trying to learn for awhile now. Maybe it will finally hit this time.
Pray for me and my writing abilities wont you?
Oh, I'm still having a blast ... I woke up in the middle of the night last night and giggled to myself when I thought of the line "a rather ponderous and unexciting essay", and it was even funnier when he said it to me in his deep English accent. What else can I do but laugh? Still missing and loving all of you.
P
"Paul
A rather ponderous and unexciting essay. You must avoid making grand and bold explanations in complex and grandiose language. Say things simply and clearly. This essay demonstrates a great deal of hard work, but little substantive thought. Too often the essay tries to explain the genesis and formulation of crusading ideology rather than identity and discussion on the expectation of the crusaders, as required by the question. The essay needed evidence and it needed examples: it supplied neither. Above all the essay failed to address the question. There was, it is true, the occasional glimpse of an effort to do so, most notably (and this is true, alas, of many essays) in the conclusion. It is too late in the conclusion. Don't lose heart, however, learn, read, and apply these points. Doing so will not only produce the goods, but will be intellectually satisfying."
:) I don't think my parents need to worry about me losing anything from my great resevior of humility while I'm here ... haha. I think most people come here and expect to attain a certain intellectual "air" about them simply because they're at Oxford. Well, I'm glad mine got shot to the ground because it was starting to get old. The good thing about yesterday is it took alot of the pressure off. This Oxford don wants me to be down to earth, real, and simple in my writing, because, he says, thats the best kind of writing. That is something I have been trying to learn for awhile now. Maybe it will finally hit this time.
Pray for me and my writing abilities wont you?
Oh, I'm still having a blast ... I woke up in the middle of the night last night and giggled to myself when I thought of the line "a rather ponderous and unexciting essay", and it was even funnier when he said it to me in his deep English accent. What else can I do but laugh? Still missing and loving all of you.
P
Sunday, 18 January 2009
Zero Week
I have to attribute the creation of this blog to my brother, who just recently told me I could create said blog for free and at the same time keep a journal that will last forever right here, on the good ole' internet. So, without being long-winded, I made it to Oxford without any problems, met a fellow Taylorian at Heathrow airport, and we took the hour bus ride from London to our new home on Pullens lane.
The title of this little blog denotes what locals refer to as the week before the start of term. To us students in the SCIO program (Scholarship and Christianity in Oxford) it meant orientation... lots of it. I am an affiliate of Wycliffe Hall, the theological college of the University, but only in terms of student life (intramural sports, clubs, etc...) and university membership (paperwork, identification cards, etc...). My identity (and everyone else's) at Oxford is found in a vast network of 'readers' (undergrads) and 'tutors' (graduate students & professors) who intermingle with each other, regardless of what college I or they belong to. 4 of the 5 weekdays past were spent at Wycliffe with our program directors discussing what we would need to know about the semester, our tutor(s)ials, and...well...everything (too much to write down).
The city is an interesting combination of old and new architecture and LOTS of history. While walking down broad street this past week I looked up to find a girl I graduated High School with staring right back (Kate Gallagher for those interested... she always helped me in the AP classes we took together whenever I needed a bailout, guess Oxford isn't the right place for that anymore). We've made plans to catch up soon. Saturday put me in London with most of the group and one of the program assistants who gave us a tour of all the famous spots (Trafalgar square, Westminster square, US embassy, Chinatown, etc...). How many times have I seen Big Ben on a television screen? Now I know its real. Today was the last of Zero Week, which means the first of an eight week term starts tomorrow, and I still have yet to start a ten page essay for my Crusades tutorial due Tuesday night. Oh, and read 900 pages for a political theory tutorial... please, who do these "Dons" think they are?
I know the phrase is overused, but this is an amazing experience. There's something to be said about living in a city renowned throughout the world for its reputation as an intellectual capital. I feel somewhat out of place in that regard, but Jesus wants me here and I am very happy to come. I love and miss you all. This post is way too long, I'll keep it shorter next time. Cheers.
The title of this little blog denotes what locals refer to as the week before the start of term. To us students in the SCIO program (Scholarship and Christianity in Oxford) it meant orientation... lots of it. I am an affiliate of Wycliffe Hall, the theological college of the University, but only in terms of student life (intramural sports, clubs, etc...) and university membership (paperwork, identification cards, etc...). My identity (and everyone else's) at Oxford is found in a vast network of 'readers' (undergrads) and 'tutors' (graduate students & professors) who intermingle with each other, regardless of what college I or they belong to. 4 of the 5 weekdays past were spent at Wycliffe with our program directors discussing what we would need to know about the semester, our tutor(s)ials, and...well...everything (too much to write down).
The city is an interesting combination of old and new architecture and LOTS of history. While walking down broad street this past week I looked up to find a girl I graduated High School with staring right back (Kate Gallagher for those interested... she always helped me in the AP classes we took together whenever I needed a bailout, guess Oxford isn't the right place for that anymore). We've made plans to catch up soon. Saturday put me in London with most of the group and one of the program assistants who gave us a tour of all the famous spots (Trafalgar square, Westminster square, US embassy, Chinatown, etc...). How many times have I seen Big Ben on a television screen? Now I know its real. Today was the last of Zero Week, which means the first of an eight week term starts tomorrow, and I still have yet to start a ten page essay for my Crusades tutorial due Tuesday night. Oh, and read 900 pages for a political theory tutorial... please, who do these "Dons" think they are?
I know the phrase is overused, but this is an amazing experience. There's something to be said about living in a city renowned throughout the world for its reputation as an intellectual capital. I feel somewhat out of place in that regard, but Jesus wants me here and I am very happy to come. I love and miss you all. This post is way too long, I'll keep it shorter next time. Cheers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)