To preface: my tutor, Dr. Hugh Doherty, is very helpful and gracious, not the harsh critic I was expecting from Oxford Professors. Here's his note to me after our first meeting yesterday (which actually went very well) discussing my first essay.
"Paul
A rather ponderous and unexciting essay. You must avoid making grand and bold explanations in complex and grandiose language. Say things simply and clearly. This essay demonstrates a great deal of hard work, but little substantive thought. Too often the essay tries to explain the genesis and formulation of crusading ideology rather than identity and discussion on the expectation of the crusaders, as required by the question. The essay needed evidence and it needed examples: it supplied neither. Above all the essay failed to address the question. There was, it is true, the occasional glimpse of an effort to do so, most notably (and this is true, alas, of many essays) in the conclusion. It is too late in the conclusion. Don't lose heart, however, learn, read, and apply these points. Doing so will not only produce the goods, but will be intellectually satisfying."
:) I don't think my parents need to worry about me losing anything from my great resevior of humility while I'm here ... haha. I think most people come here and expect to attain a certain intellectual "air" about them simply because they're at Oxford. Well, I'm glad mine got shot to the ground because it was starting to get old. The good thing about yesterday is it took alot of the pressure off. This Oxford don wants me to be down to earth, real, and simple in my writing, because, he says, thats the best kind of writing. That is something I have been trying to learn for awhile now. Maybe it will finally hit this time.
Pray for me and my writing abilities wont you?
Oh, I'm still having a blast ... I woke up in the middle of the night last night and giggled to myself when I thought of the line "a rather ponderous and unexciting essay", and it was even funnier when he said it to me in his deep English accent. What else can I do but laugh? Still missing and loving all of you.
P
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
HAHA he kind of verbally bitch slapped you. When he was done speaking you should have grabbed yourself, spit on the floor, farted and said," Oh yeah? Well writing like that comes from an American. Remember? the guys who saved your ass in the war?" and then left. May have left a bad impression...but an impression nonetheless. Haha love you man, sounds like a blast!
ReplyDeleteGonzo